Two Photons Hitting the Exact Same Molecule on Photographic Film

Great clarification! You’re asking whether two photons, arriving one at a time, have ever been observed to hit the exact same molecule or atom on a photosensitive film (like photographic film or chemically developed film).

1. Theoretical Possibility: Can It Happen?

In principle, yes, but it would be extremely difficult to detect:

• Photographic film consists of a random distribution of light-sensitive molecules (e.g., silver halide crystals in traditional film).
• A photon interacts with an individual molecule or atom, causing a chemical reaction (photo-reduction of silver halide).
• Since photons arrive one at a time, a second photon would have to interact with the exact same molecule that was already excited by the first photon.

2. Practical Challenges: Why Is This Hard to Detect?

Even if it happens, how would we know? Unlike digital detectors, where we can track exact photon arrivals, traditional film records exposure as a collective result over time. Some key challenges include:

a) Atomic-Level Precision

• In a typical photographic film, silver halide crystals are microscale to nanoscale in size, but they contain millions of atoms.
• The likelihood of a photon hitting the exact same atom is tiny, but hitting the same molecule within a crystal grain is somewhat more probable.

b) Chemical Development and Grain Structure

• When a photon hits the film, it does not leave a visible mark immediately.
• Instead, it creates a latent image, where the affected molecules form a nucleus for subsequent development.
• This means we don’t know if a second photon hit the same spot, since development amplifies clusters of exposed grains.

c) Random Distribution of Photons

• Since photons don’t communicate with each other, their arrival is dictated purely by probabilistic distribution.
• Even in a controlled experiment, where photons are sent one at a time, they follow the same wavefunction pattern but are independent.

3. Has This Ever Been Observed?

To the best of available scientific records, no experiment has directly observed two photons hitting the exact same molecule in a photographic film. However, some indirect observations suggest that photons can contribute to the same reaction center over time, including:

a) Latent Image Amplification

• If a second photon interacts with a previously excited molecule in silver halide, it could make it more likely to develop.
• This effect is known in low-light film photography, where weakly exposed grains can be enhanced by additional light exposure before development.

b) High-Sensitivity Experiments

• Experiments involving single-photon exposure of film have been done to measure quantum efficiency, but these studies focus on the formation of a latent image, not tracking multiple photons hitting the same spot.

4. Could We Design an Experiment to Test This?

While no experiment has been done specifically to detect this, in principle, one could:

1. Use an ultra-sensitive photographic film with a known single-molecule active site per grain.
2. Expose it to a single-photon source, one photon at a time, tracking how individual grains develop over repeated exposures.
3. Develop the film incrementally to see if a photon that previously failed to form a visible latent image could later be enhanced by a second photon.

5. Final Answer:

✓ Two photons hitting the exact same molecule in photographic film is theoretically possible, but detecting this is extremely difficult.
✓ There is no direct experimental confirmation that this has been observed.
✓ However, chemical processes like latent image amplification suggest that photons can contribute to the same reaction over time.
✓ A specialized experiment could be designed to test this explicitly, but current studies have not aimed to measure this effect.

🚀 Would you like to explore how we might design an experiment to test this in modern quantum optics?

Prev - Home - Next